Chantel Crane -- CSU Sacramento

Use the back button on your browser to return to the pref entry page or tournament entry list. The judge philosophy appears in a different format at the bottom of the page.

Judging philosophy:

I debated for 7 semesters, 3-4 of which in Open and can generally follow the debate.
Topicality- Used to be awesome, now has been bastardized by blippy debate. This is just like any other argument, you can't read the taglines and expect to win the debate. Every speech should be another extension of why I should listen to that argument.

K's- Once again, you have to explain these. These are also just like every other argument. You aren't going to win a DA that isn't impacted, so same applies here.

Aff K's- You need to give concrete reasons why running an aff K is alright. On that same note, the negative needs to do a good job of telling me why this isn't ok. I try to look at the round in a vacuum, so please don't make me use my brain- tell me what to do.

I want explanations and I am not going to make connections for you.

Seasonal voting record:

Tourney Div Rd AFF NEG Decision
SFSU-1 JV 1 Fresno Barton 26 Caffrey-Casiano 26.1 LRCCD Evans 27.5 Kumar 28 NEG
SFSU-1 Open 2 LRCCD Chowdhury 29.5 Stanfield 27 SntaCl Andry 27.5 Cruz 26.5 AFF
SFSU-1 Nov 3 Chico Bush 29.5 Mathis 28 Fresno Dhanjan 27 Eizadi 29 AFF
SFSU-1 Nov 4 LRCCD Gover 27.5 Priyadarshini 27 Fresno Nemat 26 Randawa 26.5 AFF
SFSU-1 JV Semi Pep Ordog 0 Yang 0 Chico Laczko 0 Trinkeller 0 NEG 2-1 (NEG)
SFSU-1 JV Final SDSU Clark 0 Won 0 Chico Laczko 0 Trinkeller 0 AFF 2-1 (AFF)
DVC-1 Open 1 CSUN Lindo 26.5 Loy 26 LRCCD Decristoforo 25 Thomson-Burns 25.5 AFF
DVC-1 Nov 2 LRCCD Brooks 28 Priyadarshini 27 SFSU Alvarez 27.5 Doc-Docorow 26 AFF
DVC-1 Nov 3 CSUN Algorri 27 Babayans 27.5 LACC Lopez 27.1 Salmeron 26 AFF
DVC-1 Open 4 PolySL Curtin 28 Young 28.5 Chico McNutt 27 Parker 27.5 NEG
DVC-1 Nov 6 LACC Ramirez 26.5 Rimular 26 CSUN/Vandy Belzberg 27 Mitchell 27.5 NEG
DVC-1 Nov Semi CSUN/Vandy Belzberg 0 Mitchell 0 Fresno Eizadi 0 Kovtun 0 NEG 2-1 (AFF)
USC JV 1 ASU Chotras 27.5 Rajan 28 CSUN Agbonwaneten 26 Harryman 25.5 AFF
USC JV 2 LRCCD Juarez 26.5 Thomson-Burns 27 CSUN Eddins 26 Martz 25.5 AFF
USC Open 5 KState Mays 28.5 Ramirez 28 IdahoS Eckert 26.5 Hand 28.1 AFF
USC JV 6 SDSU Everheart 26 King 27 CSUN Lindo 29 Pena 26.5 NEG
Berkeley Open 1 PolySL Irani 26 Samora 25.5 Chico Laczko 27.5 Parker 28 NEG
Berkeley Nov 2 CSUN Demery 27.5 Eddins 28.5 LRCCD Gover 29 Severson 28 NEG
Berkeley Nov 4 SFSU Almario 27 Khaleghi 27.5 CSUN Pena 26.5 Wofford 26 AFF
Berkeley Nov 5 CSUN Belzberg 29 Islam 27.5 PolySL Christos 29.5 Harris 28 NEG
Berkeley Nov Semi SFSU Almario 0 Khaleghi 0 CSUN Belzberg 0 Islam 0 NEG 2-1 (NEG)
CSUF JV 2 Chico/CSUF Bush 26 Gonzalez 27.5 CSUN Islam 26.5 Lindo 28 NEG
CSUF Open 3 LRCCD Chowdhury 28 Stanfield 27 Mac Goodrum 29.5 Smith 28.5 NEG
CSUF Open 5 ASU Marcus 29.5 Vered 28.7 Libert Bobbitt 29 Hedrick 28.5 AFF
CSUN Nov 1 PolySL Christos 28 Harris 28.5 SFSU Curato 27.5 Khaleghi 27 AFF
CSUN Nov 2 CSUN Martz 28.5 Wofford 28 LACC Dragon 27 Mariuta 27.5 AFF
CSUN JV 4 Fresno Barton 27.5 Caffrey-Casiano 27 PolySL Irani 26.8 Samora 26 AFF
CSUN JV 5 CSUF Gonzalez 27 Rodriguez 27.1 SFSU Hamud 29 Teter 28 NEG
CSUN JV 6 CSUF Schill 27.9 Su 27.5 ASU Chotras 28 Rajan 29 NEG
CSUN Nov Qurt CSUN Belzberg 0 Pena 0 Weber Hancock 0 Woodhall 0 AFF 2-1 (NEG)
CSUN Open Final CSUF Alvarado 0 Thach 0 SFSU Voeller 0 Turner 0 NEG 2-1 (NEG)
WestJVNov Nov 3 Fresno Mitchell 26 Tate 27 LRCCD Brooks 27.5 Priyadarshini 25.5 NEG
WestJVNov Nov 4 LRCCD Harris 26 Vlasenko 25.5 Fresno Eizadi 28 Randawa 28.5 NEG
WestJVNov JV 5 CSUN Belzberg 27.9 Harryman 27 Pep Ordog 29 Yang 28 AFF
WestJVNov JV 6 CSUN Islam 27.5 Lindo 27.9 PolySL Irani 29.5 Samora 28 NEG
WestJVNov Nov Octo CSUF Castro 0 Estrada 0 MU Roman 0 Todd 0 AFF 2-1 (AFF)
WestJVNov JV Semi Chico McGarry 0 Trinkeller 0 CSUF Alvarado 0 Su 0 NEG 2-1 (AFF)
WestJVNov JV Final CSUF Alvarado 0 Su 0 LRCCD Evans 0 Kumar 0 NEG 3-0 (NEG)
NCFASpring Open 1 PolySL Curtin 29 Irani 28.5 LRCCD Decristoforo 27 Priyadarshini 28 AFF
NCFASpring Open 2 Chico McGarry 27.4 Trinkeller 28 Pep Ordog 27.5 Yang 27 AFF
NCFASpring Open 3 LRCCD Chowdhury 26.5 Stanfield 25.5 Chico Laczko 28 Parker 28.5 AFF
NCFASpring Open 4 LRCCD Brooks 27.5 Thomson-Burns 27 Fresno Randawa 26 Galvan 28 NEG
NCFASpring Nov 5 PolySL Christos 29 Harris 28.5 SFSU LaVelle 26 Mallon 25.5 AFF
NCFASpring Nov Qurt LACC Dragon 0 Mariuta 0 PolySL Carrasco 0 Jones 0 NEG 2-1 (NEG)
D1Qual JV 1 Pep Ordog 26.5 Yang 28.5 Fresno Mitchell 27 Tate 27.5 AFF
D1Qual JV 2 ASU Chotras 29 Rajan 28.5 Fresno Galvan 26 Holley 25 AFF
D1Qual Nov 3 PolySL Kunnan 27 Witkop 28.5 ASU/CSUF Cantrell 26.5 Estrada 28 AFF
D1Qual Nov 4 PolySL Carrasco 29 Jones 28.5 CSUN Algorri 26.5 Babayans 27 AFF
D1Qual JV 5 SntaCl Cruz 28.4 Wetland 26 PolySL Curtin 28.5 Irani 27.5 NEG
D1Qual JV Qurt USC Kaiser 0 Nhan 0 CSUF Alvarado 0 Su 0 AFF 3-0 (AFF)
CEDA Open 2 ASU Marcus 28 Vered 28.7 NoTexa Fink 27 Abraha 27.7 AFF
CEDA Open 4 Towson Ruffin 28.9 Whitley 28.8 Chico Laczko 28.6 Parker 29 AFF
CEDA Open 5 ASU Dunne 28.2 Sanchez 28.1 NoTexa McCullough 28 Searles 28.5 NEG
CEDA Open 6 Chico McGarry 25 Trinkeller 27.5 L'Ville Lusco 27 Reddy 25.5 AFF
CEDA Open 7 SDSU Everheart 26 King 27 WCSU Giannini 25 Bonacci 25.5 AFF

Tourney	Div	Rd	AFF					NEG					Decision
SFSU-1	JV	1	Fresno	Barton	26	Caffrey-Casiano	26.1	LRCCD	Evans	27.5	Kumar	28	NEG
SFSU-1	Open	2	LRCCD	Chowdhury	29.5	Stanfield	27	SntaCl	Andry	27.5	Cruz	26.5	AFF
SFSU-1	Nov	3	Chico	Bush	29.5	Mathis	28	Fresno	Dhanjan	27	Eizadi	29	AFF
SFSU-1	Nov	4	LRCCD	Gover	27.5	Priyadarshini	27	Fresno	Nemat	26	Randawa	26.5	AFF
SFSU-1	JV	Semi	Pep	Ordog	0	Yang	0	Chico	Laczko	0	Trinkeller	0	NEG 2-1 (NEG)
SFSU-1	JV	Final	SDSU	Clark	0	Won	0	Chico	Laczko	0	Trinkeller	0	AFF 2-1 (AFF)
DVC-1	Open	1	CSUN	Lindo	26.5	Loy	26	LRCCD	Decristoforo	25	Thomson-Burns	25.5	AFF
DVC-1	Nov	2	LRCCD	Brooks	28	Priyadarshini	27	SFSU	Alvarez	27.5	Doc-Docorow	26	AFF
DVC-1	Nov	3	CSUN	Algorri	27	Babayans	27.5	LACC	Lopez	27.1	Salmeron	26	AFF
DVC-1	Open	4	PolySL	Curtin	28	Young	28.5	Chico	McNutt	27	Parker	27.5	NEG
DVC-1	Nov	6	LACC	Ramirez	26.5	Rimular	26	CSUN/Vandy	Belzberg	27	Mitchell	27.5	NEG
DVC-1	Nov	Semi	CSUN/Vandy	Belzberg	0	Mitchell	0	Fresno	Eizadi	0	Kovtun	0	NEG 2-1 (AFF)
USC	JV	1	ASU	Chotras	27.5	Rajan	28	CSUN	Agbonwaneten	26	Harryman	25.5	AFF
USC	JV	2	LRCCD	Juarez	26.5	Thomson-Burns	27	CSUN	Eddins	26	Martz	25.5	AFF
USC	Open	5	KState	Mays	28.5	Ramirez	28	IdahoS	Eckert	26.5	Hand	28.1	AFF
USC	JV	6	SDSU	Everheart	26	King	27	CSUN	Lindo	29	Pena	26.5	NEG
Berkeley	Open	1	PolySL	Irani	26	Samora	25.5	Chico	Laczko	27.5	Parker	28	NEG
Berkeley	Nov	2	CSUN	Demery	27.5	Eddins	28.5	LRCCD	Gover	29	Severson	28	NEG
Berkeley	Nov	4	SFSU	Almario	27	Khaleghi	27.5	CSUN	Pena	26.5	Wofford	26	AFF
Berkeley	Nov	5	CSUN	Belzberg	29	Islam	27.5	PolySL	Christos	29.5	Harris	28	NEG
Berkeley	Nov	Semi	SFSU	Almario	0	Khaleghi	0	CSUN	Belzberg	0	Islam	0	NEG 2-1 (NEG)
CSUF	JV	2	Chico/CSUF	Bush	26	Gonzalez	27.5	CSUN	Islam	26.5	Lindo	28	NEG
CSUF	Open	3	LRCCD	Chowdhury	28	Stanfield	27	Mac	Goodrum	29.5	Smith	28.5	NEG
CSUF	Open	5	ASU	Marcus	29.5	Vered	28.7	Libert	Bobbitt	29	Hedrick	28.5	AFF
CSUN	Nov	1	PolySL	Christos	28	Harris	28.5	SFSU	Curato	27.5	Khaleghi	27	AFF
CSUN	Nov	2	CSUN	Martz	28.5	Wofford	28	LACC	Dragon	27	Mariuta	27.5	AFF
CSUN	JV	4	Fresno	Barton	27.5	Caffrey-Casiano	27	PolySL	Irani	26.8	Samora	26	AFF
CSUN	JV	5	CSUF	Gonzalez	27	Rodriguez	27.1	SFSU	Hamud	29	Teter	28	NEG
CSUN	JV	6	CSUF	Schill	27.9	Su	27.5	ASU	Chotras	28	Rajan	29	NEG
CSUN	Nov	Qurt	CSUN	Belzberg	0	Pena	0	Weber	Hancock	0	Woodhall	0	AFF 2-1 (NEG)
CSUN	Open	Final	CSUF	Alvarado	0	Thach	0	SFSU	Voeller	0	Turner	0	NEG 2-1 (NEG)
WestJVNov	Nov	3	Fresno	Mitchell	26	Tate	27	LRCCD	Brooks	27.5	Priyadarshini	25.5	NEG
WestJVNov	Nov	4	LRCCD	Harris	26	Vlasenko	25.5	Fresno	Eizadi	28	Randawa	28.5	NEG
WestJVNov	JV	5	CSUN	Belzberg	27.9	Harryman	27	Pep	Ordog	29	Yang	28	AFF
WestJVNov	JV	6	CSUN	Islam	27.5	Lindo	27.9	PolySL	Irani	29.5	Samora	28	NEG
WestJVNov	Nov	Octo	CSUF	Castro	0	Estrada	0	MU	Roman	0	Todd	0	AFF 2-1 (AFF)
WestJVNov	JV	Semi	Chico	McGarry	0	Trinkeller	0	CSUF	Alvarado	0	Su	0	NEG 2-1 (AFF)
WestJVNov	JV	Final	CSUF	Alvarado	0	Su	0	LRCCD	Evans	0	Kumar	0	NEG 3-0 (NEG)
NCFASpring	Open	1	PolySL	Curtin	29	Irani	28.5	LRCCD	Decristoforo	27	Priyadarshini	28	AFF
NCFASpring	Open	2	Chico	McGarry	27.4	Trinkeller	28	Pep	Ordog	27.5	Yang	27	AFF
NCFASpring	Open	3	LRCCD	Chowdhury	26.5	Stanfield	25.5	Chico	Laczko	28	Parker	28.5	AFF
NCFASpring	Open	4	LRCCD	Brooks	27.5	Thomson-Burns	27	Fresno	Randawa	26	Galvan	28	NEG
NCFASpring	Nov	5	PolySL	Christos	29	Harris	28.5	SFSU	LaVelle	26	Mallon	25.5	AFF
NCFASpring	Nov	Qurt	LACC	Dragon	0	Mariuta	0	PolySL	Carrasco	0	Jones	0	NEG 2-1 (NEG)
D1Qual	JV	1	Pep	Ordog	26.5	Yang	28.5	Fresno	Mitchell	27	Tate	27.5	AFF
D1Qual	JV	2	ASU	Chotras	29	Rajan	28.5	Fresno	Galvan	26	Holley	25	AFF
D1Qual	Nov	3	PolySL	Kunnan	27	Witkop	28.5	ASU/CSUF	Cantrell	26.5	Estrada	28	AFF
D1Qual	Nov	4	PolySL	Carrasco	29	Jones	28.5	CSUN	Algorri	26.5	Babayans	27	AFF
D1Qual	JV	5	SntaCl	Cruz	28.4	Wetland	26	PolySL	Curtin	28.5	Irani	27.5	NEG
D1Qual	JV	Qurt	USC	Kaiser	0	Nhan	0	CSUF	Alvarado	0	Su	0	AFF 3-0 (AFF)
CEDA	Open	2	ASU	Marcus	28	Vered	28.7	NoTexa	Fink	27	Abraha	27.7	AFF
CEDA	Open	4	Towson	Ruffin	28.9	Whitley	28.8	Chico	Laczko	28.6	Parker	29	AFF
CEDA	Open	5	ASU	Dunne	28.2	Sanchez	28.1	NoTexa	McCullough	28	Searles	28.5	NEG
CEDA	Open	6	Chico	McGarry	25	Trinkeller	27.5	L'Ville	Lusco	27	Reddy	25.5	AFF
CEDA	Open	7	SDSU	Everheart	26	King	27	WCSU	Giannini	25	Bonacci	25.5	AFF

Judge Philosophy Alternate Format:

I debated for 7 semesters, 3-4 of which in Open and can generally follow the debate. Topicality- Used to be awesome, now has been bastardized by blippy debate. This is just like any other argument, you can't read the taglines and expect to win the debate. Every speech should be another extension of why I should listen to that argument. K's- Once again, you have to explain these. These are also just like every other argument. You aren't going to win a DA that isn't impacted, so same applies here. Aff K's- You need to give concrete reasons why running an aff K is alright. On that same note, the negative needs to do a good job of telling me why this isn't ok. I try to look at the round in a vacuum, so please don't make me use my brain- tell me what to do. I want explanations and I am not going to make connections for you.