Chantel Crane -- CSU Sacramento

Use the back button on your browser to return to the pref entry page or tournament entry list. The judge philosophy appears in a different format at the bottom of the page.

Judging philosophy:

I debated for 7 semesters, 3-4 of which in Open and can generally follow the debate.
Topicality- Used to be awesome, now has been bastardized by blippy debate. This is just like any other argument, you can't read the taglines and expect to win the debate. Every speech should be another extension of why I should listen to that argument.

K's- Once again, you have to explain these. These are also just like every other argument. You aren't going to win a DA that isn't impacted, so same applies here.

Aff K's- You need to give concrete reasons why running an aff K is alright. On that same note, the negative needs to do a good job of telling me why this isn't ok. I try to look at the round in a vacuum, so please don't make me use my brain- tell me what to do.


I want explanations and I am not going to make connections for you.


Seasonal voting record:

TourneyDivRdAFF    NEG    Decision
SFSU-1JV1FresnoBarton26Caffrey-Casiano26.1LRCCDEvans27.5Kumar28NEG
SFSU-1Open2LRCCDChowdhury29.5Stanfield27SntaClAndry27.5Cruz26.5AFF
SFSU-1Nov3ChicoBush29.5Mathis28FresnoDhanjan27Eizadi29AFF
SFSU-1Nov4LRCCDGover27.5Priyadarshini27FresnoNemat26Randawa26.5AFF
SFSU-1JVSemiPepOrdog0Yang0ChicoLaczko0Trinkeller0NEG 2-1 (NEG)
SFSU-1JVFinalSDSUClark0Won0ChicoLaczko0Trinkeller0AFF 2-1 (AFF)
DVC-1Open1CSUNLindo26.5Loy26LRCCDDecristoforo25Thomson-Burns25.5AFF
DVC-1Nov2LRCCDBrooks28Priyadarshini27SFSUAlvarez27.5Doc-Docorow26AFF
DVC-1Nov3CSUNAlgorri27Babayans27.5LACCLopez27.1Salmeron26AFF
DVC-1Open4PolySLCurtin28Young28.5ChicoMcNutt27Parker27.5NEG
DVC-1Nov6LACCRamirez26.5Rimular26CSUN/VandyBelzberg27Mitchell27.5NEG
DVC-1NovSemiCSUN/VandyBelzberg0Mitchell0FresnoEizadi0Kovtun0NEG 2-1 (AFF)
USCJV1ASUChotras27.5Rajan28CSUNAgbonwaneten26Harryman25.5AFF
USCJV2LRCCDJuarez26.5Thomson-Burns27CSUNEddins26Martz25.5AFF
USCOpen5KStateMays28.5Ramirez28IdahoSEckert26.5Hand28.1AFF
USCJV6SDSUEverheart26King27CSUNLindo29Pena26.5NEG
BerkeleyOpen1PolySLIrani26Samora25.5ChicoLaczko27.5Parker28NEG
BerkeleyNov2CSUNDemery27.5Eddins28.5LRCCDGover29Severson28NEG
BerkeleyNov4SFSUAlmario27Khaleghi27.5CSUNPena26.5Wofford26AFF
BerkeleyNov5CSUNBelzberg29Islam27.5PolySLChristos29.5Harris28NEG
BerkeleyNovSemiSFSUAlmario0Khaleghi0CSUNBelzberg0Islam0NEG 2-1 (NEG)
CSUFJV2Chico/CSUFBush26Gonzalez27.5CSUNIslam26.5Lindo28NEG
CSUFOpen3LRCCDChowdhury28Stanfield27MacGoodrum29.5Smith28.5NEG
CSUFOpen5ASUMarcus29.5Vered28.7LibertBobbitt29Hedrick28.5AFF
CSUNNov1PolySLChristos28Harris28.5SFSUCurato27.5Khaleghi27AFF
CSUNNov2CSUNMartz28.5Wofford28LACCDragon27Mariuta27.5AFF
CSUNJV4FresnoBarton27.5Caffrey-Casiano27PolySLIrani26.8Samora26AFF
CSUNJV5CSUFGonzalez27Rodriguez27.1SFSUHamud29Teter28NEG
CSUNJV6CSUFSchill27.9Su27.5ASUChotras28Rajan29NEG
CSUNNovQurtCSUNBelzberg0Pena0WeberHancock0Woodhall0AFF 2-1 (NEG)
CSUNOpenFinalCSUFAlvarado0Thach0SFSUVoeller0Turner0NEG 2-1 (NEG)
WestJVNovNov3FresnoMitchell26Tate27LRCCDBrooks27.5Priyadarshini25.5NEG
WestJVNovNov4LRCCDHarris26Vlasenko25.5FresnoEizadi28Randawa28.5NEG
WestJVNovJV5CSUNBelzberg27.9Harryman27PepOrdog29Yang28AFF
WestJVNovJV6CSUNIslam27.5Lindo27.9PolySLIrani29.5Samora28NEG
WestJVNovNovOctoCSUFCastro0Estrada0MURoman0Todd0AFF 2-1 (AFF)
WestJVNovJVSemiChicoMcGarry0Trinkeller0CSUFAlvarado0Su0NEG 2-1 (AFF)
WestJVNovJVFinalCSUFAlvarado0Su0LRCCDEvans0Kumar0NEG 3-0 (NEG)
NCFASpringOpen1PolySLCurtin29Irani28.5LRCCDDecristoforo27Priyadarshini28AFF
NCFASpringOpen2ChicoMcGarry27.4Trinkeller28PepOrdog27.5Yang27AFF
NCFASpringOpen3LRCCDChowdhury26.5Stanfield25.5ChicoLaczko28Parker28.5AFF
NCFASpringOpen4LRCCDBrooks27.5Thomson-Burns27FresnoRandawa26Galvan28NEG
NCFASpringNov5PolySLChristos29Harris28.5SFSULaVelle26Mallon25.5AFF
NCFASpringNovQurtLACCDragon0Mariuta0PolySLCarrasco0Jones0NEG 2-1 (NEG)
D1QualJV1PepOrdog26.5Yang28.5FresnoMitchell27Tate27.5AFF
D1QualJV2ASUChotras29Rajan28.5FresnoGalvan26Holley25AFF
D1QualNov3PolySLKunnan27Witkop28.5ASU/CSUFCantrell26.5Estrada28AFF
D1QualNov4PolySLCarrasco29Jones28.5CSUNAlgorri26.5Babayans27AFF
D1QualJV5SntaClCruz28.4Wetland26PolySLCurtin28.5Irani27.5NEG
D1QualJVQurtUSCKaiser0Nhan0CSUFAlvarado0Su0AFF 3-0 (AFF)
CEDAOpen2ASUMarcus28Vered28.7NoTexaFink27Abraha27.7AFF
CEDAOpen4TowsonRuffin28.9Whitley28.8ChicoLaczko28.6Parker29AFF
CEDAOpen5ASUDunne28.2Sanchez28.1NoTexaMcCullough28Searles28.5NEG
CEDAOpen6ChicoMcGarry25Trinkeller27.5L'VilleLusco27Reddy25.5AFF
CEDAOpen7SDSUEverheart26King27WCSUGiannini25Bonacci25.5AFF

Judge Philosophy Alternate Format: