Robbie Goodrich -- Rutgers-Newark

Use the back button on your browser to return to the pref entry page or tournament entry list. The judge philosophy appears in a different format at the bottom of the page.

Judging philosophy:

Robbie Goodrich
Currently-Rutgers Assistant
Former D 8 Coach and Debater @ WCSU
3rd Year Coaching and Judging

I believe debate has a significant educational value that goes far beyond research and accumulation of knowledge. Therefore I consider debate a unique pedagogical experience and the participants should act accordingly.

Paperless Debate: Novices catch a break. JV and Open, “all time” in between speeches that is not CX will be Prep. If both teams agree to an alternative then so will I.

Decision Calculus: “…each decision is different and requires an absolutely unique interpretation, which no existing, coded rule can or ought to guarantee completely…” Derrida 1990

I will place a high value on your performance and will evaluate your Ethical stance, use of Logic, and Pathos.
I understand debates that are technical and treat the activity as a game and judge them accordingly.
I love debates that examine the historical and socio-cultural significance of law.
I place a significant value on growing a productive reflexivity within debate and enjoy debates about debate.

Seasonal voting record:

Tourney Div Rd AFF NEG Decision
WestPt Nov 1 MU Breder 27.3 Sullivan 27.5 CUNY Khan 27.2 Torres 27 AFF
WestPt JV 2 Libert Scott 27.6 Trujillo 27.3 CUNY Glysantseva 27.8 Torre 27.1 AFF
WestPt Nov 3 CUNY Aslam 28.2 Avrakh 27.7 MiaFL Butler 27.5 Jessani 28 AFF
WestPt Nov 4 Clarion McFadden 27 Siegel 27.3 MiaFL Benavides 26.8 Rojas 27.1 AFF
WestPt Nov 5 CUNY Correa 27 Figueroa 27.2 Rochstr Ahmed 27.8 Norbu 28 NEG
WestPt Nov Qurt Libert Murray 0 Walker 0 CUNY Cedeno 0 McIntyre 0 AFF 2-1 (AFF)
Navy JV 1 Libert Holland 27.2 Rossdeutscher 28.2 Army Burroughs 27 Hauptman 27.5 AFF
Navy JV 2 Libert Febrizio 27.6 Lotspeich 27.3 Army Davis 27.5 Hodgkins 28 NEG
Navy JV 3 Army Allen 27.3 Cornelius 27.5 Libert Scott 27.2 Trujillo 27 NEG
Navy Nov 5 FSU Harrington 27.8 Nakagama 27.3 JamesM Rand 27 Spiker 27.5 AFF
Navy Nov 6 JamesM Ruraraju 27.8 Schrer 27.7 Army Spikol 27.6 Warren 28 AFF
Navy Nov 7 GeoMas Ahmad 27.4 Kostiuk 27.6 Libert Edwards 27.8 Gardner 27 NEG
Navy Open 8 GeoMas Lastovica 28.2 Nichols 28.4 SMU Marzullo 26.5 Murray 27.5 AFF
Monmouth JV 1 Wilkes Nardone 26.5 Seman 27.1 Crnl Kuo 27 Naqvi 27.2 NEG
Monmouth JV 2 Rochstr Davidge 26.5 Taylor 27.5 Crnl Chen 27.2 Gunn 27.4 NEG
Monmouth Nov 5 Crnl Dong 27 Zuckerman 26.5 Bing DellaRocco 27.5 Dogaroiu 27.8 NEG
Monmouth Nov 6 Bing Evans 27.5 Frumkin 27.4 Crnl Matos 27.8 Rasch 26.8 AFF
Monmouth JV Octo Libert Holguin 0 Scott 0 Crnl Chen 0 Gunn 0 AFF 3-0 (AFF)
Rutgers Nov 2 NYU Gordon-Koster 27.7 Spaulding 27.2 Libert Aharrah 27.4 Simmons 28 NEG
Rutgers Nov 3 Libert Edwards 27.8 Hilliard 27.3 MU Dellera 26.4 Maynor 26.5 AFF
Rutgers Nov 4 NYU Grant 28.1 Kim 28.2 Libert Bridwell 28.3 Laremore 28.4 NEG
Rutgers JV 5 NYU Trench 27.5 Vera 27 MU Giordano 27.8 Peguero 27.4 NEG
Rutgers Open 6 Bing Choudhury 27.3 Reddick 28.3 CUNY Cheung 28 Forbes 28.5 NEG
Rutgers JV Qurt NS Fowle 0 Lowenthal 0 Libert Apthorp 0 Edwards 0 NEG 2-1 (NEG)
Rutgers Nov Semi MU Roman 0 Todd 0 Libert Edwards 0 Hilliard 0 NEG 3-0 (NEG)
D7Qual JV 1 JamesM Glomb 27 Norby 27.8 Libert Holland 27.3 Simmons 27.2 AFF
D7Qual JV 2 JamesM Evans 27.8 Knittel 27.7 Libert Aharrah 27.6 Hilliard 27.3 AFF
D7Qual JV 3 JamesM Rand 27.6 Spiker 27.3 Libert Edwards 28.2 Gardner 27.9 NEG
D7Qual JV 4 GeoMas Bradley 28.2 Stone 28.6 Libert Murray 28.1 Walker 28 AFF
D7Qual Open 8 Towson Evans 28.6 Morgan 28.7 GTown Coles 28.3 Vale 28.2 AFF
D7Qual JV Qurt Libert Bridwell 0 Laremore 0 GeoMas Miyares 0 Woodward 0 NEG 2-1 (NEG)
D7Qual JV Semi GeoMas Miyares 0 Woodward 0 JamesM Evans 0 Knittel 0 AFF 3-0 (AFF)

Tourney	Div	Rd	AFF					NEG					Decision
WestPt	Nov	1	MU	Breder	27.3	Sullivan	27.5	CUNY	Khan	27.2	Torres	27	AFF
WestPt	JV	2	Libert	Scott	27.6	Trujillo	27.3	CUNY	Glysantseva	27.8	Torre	27.1	AFF
WestPt	Nov	3	CUNY	Aslam	28.2	Avrakh	27.7	MiaFL	Butler	27.5	Jessani	28	AFF
WestPt	Nov	4	Clarion	McFadden	27	Siegel	27.3	MiaFL	Benavides	26.8	Rojas	27.1	AFF
WestPt	Nov	5	CUNY	Correa	27	Figueroa	27.2	Rochstr	Ahmed	27.8	Norbu	28	NEG
WestPt	Nov	Qurt	Libert	Murray	0	Walker	0	CUNY	Cedeno	0	McIntyre	0	AFF 2-1 (AFF)
Navy	JV	1	Libert	Holland	27.2	Rossdeutscher	28.2	Army	Burroughs	27	Hauptman	27.5	AFF
Navy	JV	2	Libert	Febrizio	27.6	Lotspeich	27.3	Army	Davis	27.5	Hodgkins	28	NEG
Navy	JV	3	Army	Allen	27.3	Cornelius	27.5	Libert	Scott	27.2	Trujillo	27	NEG
Navy	Nov	5	FSU	Harrington	27.8	Nakagama	27.3	JamesM	Rand	27	Spiker	27.5	AFF
Navy	Nov	6	JamesM	Ruraraju	27.8	Schrer	27.7	Army	Spikol	27.6	Warren	28	AFF
Navy	Nov	7	GeoMas	Ahmad	27.4	Kostiuk	27.6	Libert	Edwards	27.8	Gardner	27	NEG
Navy	Open	8	GeoMas	Lastovica	28.2	Nichols	28.4	SMU	Marzullo	26.5	Murray	27.5	AFF
Monmouth	JV	1	Wilkes	Nardone	26.5	Seman	27.1	Crnl	Kuo	27	Naqvi	27.2	NEG
Monmouth	JV	2	Rochstr	Davidge	26.5	Taylor	27.5	Crnl	Chen	27.2	Gunn	27.4	NEG
Monmouth	Nov	5	Crnl	Dong	27	Zuckerman	26.5	Bing	DellaRocco	27.5	Dogaroiu	27.8	NEG
Monmouth	Nov	6	Bing	Evans	27.5	Frumkin	27.4	Crnl	Matos	27.8	Rasch	26.8	AFF
Monmouth	JV	Octo	Libert	Holguin	0	Scott	0	Crnl	Chen	0	Gunn	0	AFF 3-0 (AFF)
Rutgers	Nov	2	NYU	Gordon-Koster	27.7	Spaulding	27.2	Libert	Aharrah	27.4	Simmons	28	NEG
Rutgers	Nov	3	Libert	Edwards	27.8	Hilliard	27.3	MU	Dellera	26.4	Maynor	26.5	AFF
Rutgers	Nov	4	NYU	Grant	28.1	Kim	28.2	Libert	Bridwell	28.3	Laremore	28.4	NEG
Rutgers	JV	5	NYU	Trench	27.5	Vera	27	MU	Giordano	27.8	Peguero	27.4	NEG
Rutgers	Open	6	Bing	Choudhury	27.3	Reddick	28.3	CUNY	Cheung	28	Forbes	28.5	NEG
Rutgers	JV	Qurt	NS	Fowle	0	Lowenthal	0	Libert	Apthorp	0	Edwards	0	NEG 2-1 (NEG)
Rutgers	Nov	Semi	MU	Roman	0	Todd	0	Libert	Edwards	0	Hilliard	0	NEG 3-0 (NEG)
D7Qual	JV	1	JamesM	Glomb	27	Norby	27.8	Libert	Holland	27.3	Simmons	27.2	AFF
D7Qual	JV	2	JamesM	Evans	27.8	Knittel	27.7	Libert	Aharrah	27.6	Hilliard	27.3	AFF
D7Qual	JV	3	JamesM	Rand	27.6	Spiker	27.3	Libert	Edwards	28.2	Gardner	27.9	NEG
D7Qual	JV	4	GeoMas	Bradley	28.2	Stone	28.6	Libert	Murray	28.1	Walker	28	AFF
D7Qual	Open	8	Towson	Evans	28.6	Morgan	28.7	GTown	Coles	28.3	Vale	28.2	AFF
D7Qual	JV	Qurt	Libert	Bridwell	0	Laremore	0	GeoMas	Miyares	0	Woodward	0	NEG 2-1 (NEG)
D7Qual	JV	Semi	GeoMas	Miyares	0	Woodward	0	JamesM	Evans	0	Knittel	0	AFF 3-0 (AFF)

Judge Philosophy Alternate Format:

Robbie Goodrich Currently-Rutgers Assistant Former D 8 Coach and Debater @ WCSU 3rd Year Coaching and Judging I believe debate has a significant educational value that goes far beyond research and accumulation of knowledge. Therefore I consider debate a unique pedagogical experience and the participants should act accordingly. Paperless Debate: Novices catch a break. JV and Open, “all time” in between speeches that is not CX will be Prep. If both teams agree to an alternative then so will I. Decision Calculus: “…each decision is different and requires an absolutely unique interpretation, which no existing, coded rule can or ought to guarantee completely…” Derrida 1990 I will place a high value on your performance and will evaluate your Ethical stance, use of Logic, and Pathos. I understand debates that are technical and treat the activity as a game and judge them accordingly. I love debates that examine the historical and socio-cultural significance of law. I place a significant value on growing a productive reflexivity within debate and enjoy debates about debate.