Kaitlin Christian -- U.S. Military Academy

Use the back button on your browser to return to the pref entry page or tournament entry list. The judge philosophy appears in a different format at the bottom of the page.

Judging philosophy:

West Point debater.

I like policy arguments and debates in which the merits and drawbacks of policies are debated. I don't mind Topicality arguments as long as it is very obvious the other team is non topical. I am not a huge fan of K's, but I don't mind you running them as long as you actually understand what the argument is saying. I like hearing new arguments and I want us all to leave the round with a better understanding of the topics and better real world policy applications.

Seasonal voting record:

Tourney Div Rd AFF NEG Decision
BingHmpt Nov 2 JamesM Roberts 25.5 Sheffield 25.6 Crnl Ahn 26 Strombek 25.4 AFF
BingHmpt Nov 3 WCSU Pasquence 26.5 Wolff 26.7 Libert Aharrah 28 Fleming 29 AFF
BingHmpt Nov 5 WCSU Giannini 26 LaFlamme 27 Clarion/Libert McFadden 28 Simmons 27.5 NEG
BingHmpt Nov 6 WCSU Barsalou 26 Mullally 25 Libert Bridwell 29 Laremore 28 NEG
WestPt Nov 2 JamesM Glomb 28.5 Schrer 29 GeoMas Ahmad 28 Kostiuk 27.5 AFF
WestPt Nov 3 CUNY Acevedo 27.8 Giraldo 27.5 Newark Thribhu 28 Williams 27 AFF
WestPt Nov 4 JamesM Kindel 28 Sheffield 27.8 NYU Grant 27.6 Kim 27.4 NEG
Rutgers Nov 2 MU Kellog 28.5 Reiskopf 27 Libert Edwards 29 Hilliard 28 NEG
Rutgers Nov 3 Libert Murray 29 Walker 29 MU Bell 27 Sullivan 28 AFF
Rutgers Nov 4 MU Roman 26 Todd 28.5 Libert Gardner 29 Holland 26.5 NEG
Rutgers Nov 5 MU DeTommaso 29 Sime 27 Libert Aharrah 28 Simmons 28.5 NEG
Rutgers Nov Octo Libert Edwards 0 Hilliard 0 BosCol Ferguson 0 Shnipes 0 AFF 2-1 (AFF)

Tourney	Div	Rd	AFF					NEG					Decision
BingHmpt	Nov	2	JamesM	Roberts	25.5	Sheffield	25.6	Crnl	Ahn	26	Strombek	25.4	AFF
BingHmpt	Nov	3	WCSU	Pasquence	26.5	Wolff	26.7	Libert	Aharrah	28	Fleming	29	AFF
BingHmpt	Nov	5	WCSU	Giannini	26	LaFlamme	27	Clarion/Libert	McFadden	28	Simmons	27.5	NEG
BingHmpt	Nov	6	WCSU	Barsalou	26	Mullally	25	Libert	Bridwell	29	Laremore	28	NEG
WestPt	Nov	2	JamesM	Glomb	28.5	Schrer	29	GeoMas	Ahmad	28	Kostiuk	27.5	AFF
WestPt	Nov	3	CUNY	Acevedo	27.8	Giraldo	27.5	Newark	Thribhu	28	Williams	27	AFF
WestPt	Nov	4	JamesM	Kindel	28	Sheffield	27.8	NYU	Grant	27.6	Kim	27.4	NEG
Rutgers	Nov	2	MU	Kellog	28.5	Reiskopf	27	Libert	Edwards	29	Hilliard	28	NEG
Rutgers	Nov	3	Libert	Murray	29	Walker	29	MU	Bell	27	Sullivan	28	AFF
Rutgers	Nov	4	MU	Roman	26	Todd	28.5	Libert	Gardner	29	Holland	26.5	NEG
Rutgers	Nov	5	MU	DeTommaso	29	Sime	27	Libert	Aharrah	28	Simmons	28.5	NEG
Rutgers	Nov	Octo	Libert	Edwards	0	Hilliard	0	BosCol	Ferguson	0	Shnipes	0	AFF 2-1 (AFF)

Judge Philosophy Alternate Format:

West Point debater. I like policy arguments and debates in which the merits and drawbacks of policies are debated. I don't mind Topicality arguments as long as it is very obvious the other team is non topical. I am not a huge fan of K's, but I don't mind you running them as long as you actually understand what the argument is saying. I like hearing new arguments and I want us all to leave the round with a better understanding of the topics and better real world policy applications.